Loyal users kept paying Tamara, and got nothing back for it.
The Overview
Tamara Smart is Tamara's first membership programme, created to enhance the repayment experience through exclusive benefits and greater financial flexibility. As part of a team with a Senior Product Designer and UX Researcher, I led the work on the onboarding experience, which is the focus of this case study, while my teammate focused on the repayment experience.
The Problem
Tamara customers often used multiple BNPL providers interchangeably, giving them little reason to choose Tamara consistently. We needed to create meaningful value that increased loyalty.
The Business Objectives
As Tamara grew, we needed to expand beyond our core BNPL offering. The opportunity was to introduce our first paid membership, delivering tangible value to customers while creating a new recurring revenue stream for the business.
Results
↑ 10%
Adoption in first 2 months
↑ $1.6 million
In estimated recurring revenue
↑ 40K members
Tamara Smart members after beta
STARTING WITH RESEARCH
We conducted 20 in-depth user interviews to uncover the real pain points.
To understand how a membership programme could be beneficial for our users, we took a step back and with the help of a UX Researcher conducted 20 in-depth user interviews to understand their current pain points and expectations.
1. Anxiety after using Tamara
After using Tamara, many users felt stressed, constantly keeping track of multiple payments. This led to feelings of anxiety and a negative emotional association with Tamara.
2. Lack of rewards for loyal users
Loyal Tamara users felt they deserved exclusive benefits like discounts, premium support, and rewards to acknowledge their continued engagement.
3. Lack of protection from Tamara
Users expected Tamara to provide protection when ordering from merchants. They wanted assurance that if a merchant scammed them or if their items didn't match the online description, Tamara would step in.
Exploring First Solutions
Memberships were already common in the GCC, so we took a more innovative approach.
In our first iteration, we decided to give users as much flexibility as possible. Instead of paying a fixed amount each month, they could choose from three options for how much they wanted to pay. This gave users more control but introduced complexity.
USABILITY TESTING & SETBACKS
Our early concepts were too complex for users.
In our effort to create a unique membership experience that stands out in the market, we designed an engaging yet novel user flow. While the goal was clear, we faced challenges in balancing innovation with usability.
Despite several iterations, the concept was ultimately too complex. Usability testing confirmed our hypothesis: the steep learning curve of the novel approach negatively impacted the programme's usability.
DEFINING SUCCESS AND PRIORITISING GOALS
Instead of building the membership for all users, we decided to prioritise our “healthy” users: frequent customers who were more likely to see value in the membership and opt in.
While research showed that users wanted the ability to postpone payments, we chose to focus the initial launch on consolidating their payments into a simpler, more predictable experience. The plan was to validate the membership first, then explore payment postponement and minimum-payment options in a later phase.
We focused on three key success criteria, with each solution designed to directly address the pain points uncovered through research.
Drive membership adoption and revenue
Release an MVP with core features within one quarter.
Simplify repayment and reduce anxiety
Allow users to pay everything in one day rather than several dates.
Reward loyal users for choosing Tamara
Offer Tamara users cash back and buyer protection so that they feel valued and pick Tamara more consistently.
Solution
Here are the key features we shipped
1. Rewarding loyal users
Introducing cashback, rewards, and buyer protection for Tamara Smart members, ensuring they feel valued and secure when shopping with Tamara merchants.
2. Monthly pay date
Pooling all user payments on the 1st of the month to match salary payments, making tracking easier and less stressful. Members no longer need to remember multiple dates.
3. Simplifying onboarding flows
A simple onboarding flow that highlights payment screen changes for Tamara Smart members, helping users quickly adapt to the new UI.
4. Simplified opt-in flow
A seamless and intuitive opt-in flow from checkout, making it easy for users to discover Tamara Smart and join the programme without friction.
Design System
Local components built for Tamara Smart
Outcome
Impact after launch
↑ 10%
Adoption in first 2 months
↑ $1.6 million
In estimated recurring revenue
↑ 40K members
Tamara Smart members after beta
After launching the Tamara Smart membership programme, it achieved a 10% adoption rate in its first two months. Today, the programme is one of Tamara's key revenue drivers.
Reflection
My key takeaways and learnings
Simplicity wins over novelty
Our early iterations were too complex. Usability testing showed users prefer familiar, intuitive patterns over novel but confusing ones. The simpler we made the flow, the better the adoption.
Prioritise ruthlessly under tight deadlines
With a fixed launch date, we couldn't build everything users asked for. Deciding what to prioritise, starting with our healthy users and simpler, consolidated payments, let us hone the experience for one specific user instead of shipping a diluted version for everyone.